• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Darin Gibby

Author • Speaker • Lawyer

  • Home
  • About Darin
  • Books
    • Chasing Hindy
    • Gil
    • The Vintage Club
    • Why Has America Stopped Inventing?
      • Museum of Models Brochure
      • Historical Patent Documents
      • What is a Patent Model?
      • Bring Back the Model Requirement
      • Patents with Patent Models
      • Famous Patent Battles
  • Events
  • Media
    • Darin Gibby
    • Chasing Hindy Media
    • Gil
    • The Vintage Club
    • Why Has America Stopped Inventing?
  • Blog
    • Author
    • Patents
  • Contact
  • Nav Social Menu

Patenting has always been a messy business

Patenting has always been a messy business

September 12, 2016 by

Patenting has always been a messy business

Patenting has always been a messy business, and America has always struggled with how to protect its inventors, according to Darin Gibby in this book. A modern inventor faces a drawn-out and expensive battle with the Patent Office in applying for a patent, and the cost rises to millions of dollars if the patentee seeks to enforce a patent, with very little certainty at the end of the process. But America’s first inventors also encountered hardships and obstacles in protect their creations. * Eli Whitney provided a tremendous boost to the American economy by inventing a machine that removed seeds from cotton, but he tried to charge too much and courts refused to uphold his patent. * Charles Goodyear spent years trying to make a rubber that did not melt in hot weather. When he finally invented the vulcanization process, his invention was stolen and he faced years of litigation to protect his rights. * Sam Colt would have gone bankrupt if he had not been saved by the war in Mexico which increased demand for his patented gun. * Samuel Morse struggled for a long time to convince the government to install telegraph lines to take advantage of his invention, and when funding became available he was forced into patent battles against blatant infringers. * Isaac Singer created the most popular sewing machine, but became ensnared in a patent battle over the prior patent rights of Elias Howe. Problems with overlapping patents were eventually resolved by the creation of a patent licensing pool, and Howe became a millionaire even though he never produced a commercially viable sewing machine. The book also includes stories about Cyrus McCormick, Alexander Graham Bell, George Baldwin Selden (a patent attorney whom the author describes as the first patent troll), Guglielmo Marconi, Thomas Edison and the Wright Brothers. According to the author, if America’s golden days of invention are to be revived, it will be necessary to create a more efficient equitable process for protecting inventions. His specific recommendations include: * Reintroduce the requirement for patent applicants to produce working models of their inventions. * Abolish the obviousness standard and the doctrine of equivalents. * Reduce the twenty year patent term to ten years. * Curtail the continuation practice which keeps patent applications pending for years. * Go to a first-to-file system in place of the first-to-invent system. Interestingly enough, the last of the author’s recommendations is already being implemented in the America Invents Act of 2011. Do his other recommendations actually solve the problems with patents that the rest of the book so vividly illustrate? They might help, but it seems to me that a significant problem illustrated by the stories is the ability of the patentee to use the patent monopoly capriciously to hold up progress. If useful inventions are encouraged by the prospect of huge rewards, then surely it is possible to structure those rewards in a manner less antagonistic to the interests of society, for example by means of a compulsory licensing scheme whereby the inventor is rewarded with royalties but cannot prevent others from using and building upon his or her invention. If it was feasible, such a scheme could potentially make patents much less expensive to enforce and much less of a threat to industries. I thoroughly enjoyed reading about many of America’s famous inventors, and contemplating the author’s ideas for reform.

John Gibbs,
Amazon.com

Darin Gibby
2016-09-12T14:24:34+00:00

John Gibbs,
Amazon.com

Patenting has always been a messy business, and America has always struggled with how to protect its inventors, according to Darin Gibby in this book. A modern inventor faces a drawn-out and expensive battle with the Patent Office in applying for a patent, and the cost rises to millions of dollars if the patentee seeks to enforce a patent, with very little certainty at the end of the process. But America’s first inventors also encountered hardships and obstacles in protect their creations. * Eli Whitney provided a tremendous boost to the American economy by inventing a machine that removed seeds from cotton, but he tried to charge too much and courts refused to uphold his patent. * Charles Goodyear spent years trying to make a rubber that did not melt in hot weather. When he finally invented the vulcanization process, his invention was stolen and he faced years of litigation to protect his rights. * Sam Colt would have gone bankrupt if he had not been saved by the war in Mexico which increased demand for his patented gun. * Samuel Morse struggled for a long time to convince the government to install telegraph lines to take advantage of his invention, and when funding became available he was forced into patent battles against blatant infringers. * Isaac Singer created the most popular sewing machine, but became ensnared in a patent battle over the prior patent rights of Elias Howe. Problems with overlapping patents were eventually resolved by the creation of a patent licensing pool, and Howe became a millionaire even though he never produced a commercially viable sewing machine. The book also includes stories about Cyrus McCormick, Alexander Graham Bell, George Baldwin Selden (a patent attorney whom the author describes as the first patent troll), Guglielmo Marconi, Thomas Edison and...
https://www.daringibby.com/testimonials/patenting-has-always-been-a-messy-business/

Primary Sidebar

Books

Recent Posts

Review of The Lincoln Highway by Amor Towles

March 6, 2022

Fall In Yosemite

October 26, 2021

The Vintage Club now on Audible!

October 29, 2020

East Troublesome Fire in Rocky Mountain National Park

October 25, 2020

Update on Racketeering With Revolvers

September 2, 2020

Footer

Darin Gibby © 2016 All Rights Reserved
Website by Dalitopia
Copyright © 2023 ·Genesis Sample Theme - Genesis Framework by StudioPress - WordPress - Log in